Cross-Text Connections

These questions give you two short passages and ask how the ideas or arguments relate to each other.

What They Look Like

Text 1

In a study of the benefits of having free time, Marissa Sharif found that the reported sense of life satisfaction tended to plateau when participants had two hours of free time per day and actually began to fall when they had five hours of free time per day. After further research, Sharif concluded that this dip in life satisfaction mainly occurred when individuals spent all their free time unproductively, such as by watching TV or playing games.

Text 2

Psychologist James Maddux cautions against suggesting an ideal amount of free time. The human desire for both free time and productivity is universal, but Maddux asserts that individuals have unique needs for life satisfaction. Furthermore, he points out that there is no objective definition for what constitutes productivity; reading a book might be considered a productive activity by some, but idleness by others.

Based on the texts, how would Maddux (Text 2) most likely respond to the conclusion Sharif (Text 1) reached after her further research?

A) By acknowledging that free time is more likely to enhance life satisfaction when it is spent productively than when it is spent unproductively

B) By challenging the reasoning in Text 1, as it has not been proved that productivity commonly contributes to individuals' life satisfaction

C) By warning against making an overly broad assumption, as there is no clear consensus in distinguishing between productive and unproductive activities

D) By claiming that the specific activities named in Text 1 are actually examples of productive activities rather than unproductive ones

What to Know

Approach

Test every choice against both Text 1 and Text 2 before picking.

The right answer has to work for both. A choice that captures one text perfectly but misreads the other is the most common trap.

Watch out

Answers that accurately describe one text but misrepresent the other. Always check each answer against both passages.

Relationship Types

Relationship What to Look For
Disagreement Authors take opposite positions on the same issue
Partial Agreement Authors agree on some points but differ on others
Extension Author 2 builds on or adds to Author 1's point
Qualification Author 2 accepts Author 1's point but adds limits or caveats

Quick Reference by Question Type

Question Type What to Look For
"How would Author 2 respond?" What Text 2 would DISPUTE about Text 1. Watch for "concede" answers—does Text 2 actually agree to anything?
"What do both agree on?" Common ground: shared assumptions, points neither disputes
"What's the difference?" The fundamental conflict—often about interpretation, scope, or methodology

Training

Training 1: Sloths
Text 1

Scientists can learn a lot about the Hispaniolan ground sloth and other prehistoric sloths from their fossils. But it can be hard to study sloths alive today. In the wild, the Linnaeus's two-toed sloth and other sloths spend most of their time in trees. They're difficult to observe because of their excellent camouflage and slow movements.

Text 2

Rebecca Cliffe and other scientists can now record the previously hidden activities of tree-dwelling sloths by using a backpack monitor. Such monitors can provide information to correct misconceptions. It was long believed that sloths are slow because of laziness. But, in fact, sloths' slow movements are useful. Being slow protects them from predators with keen eyesight.

The author of Text 1 and the author of Text 2 both discuss which topic?

A) The scientific study of sloths

B) How climate change affects sloths

C) The techniques scientists use to care for sloths

D) The differences between prehistoric and living sloths

Stop
Cover the answers. In one short phrase, what subject is BOTH texts about? Then check your phrase against Text 1 AND Text 2 before looking at the choices.
Show answer
1

Step 1: Position each text.

Text 1Text 2
Studying sloths is hard — fossils tell us about prehistoric ones, and living ones are tough to observe (camouflage, slow, up in trees)A new tool (a backpack monitor) lets scientists finally record what living sloths do, correcting old misconceptions
2

Step 2: Find the shared subject.

Both texts are about scientifically studying sloths — Text 1 on why it's difficult, Text 2 on a tool that gets around the difficulty.

3

Step 3: Test each answer against both texts.

AnswerText 1?Text 2?
A) The scientific study of sloths✓ studying is hard✓ a tool to study them
B) How climate change affects sloths✗ not mentioned✗ not mentioned
C) Techniques scientists use to care for sloths✗ about studying, not care✗ monitoring isn't caretaking
D) Differences between prehistoric and living slothsmentions both✗ only discusses living sloths

Only A works for BOTH texts.

Answer: A

Note: On "what do both discuss," the classic trap is a choice that fits only ONE text. D is true of Text 1 (it mentions prehistoric and living sloths), but Text 2 never touches prehistoric sloths — so it fails the both-texts test. The answer is the subject they share.

Training 2: Music Albums
Text 1

In the past, music albums were created to be played back on physical formats like records. A typical record holds only about twenty-five minutes of music on each of its shiny black sides. This forced artists and producers to think carefully about what music to include on an album and what to leave out. Today's artists don't have to worry as much about fitting their music on physical formats. For this reason, many of today's artists are making albums that are much longer than albums from decades past.

Text 2

In today's digital age, most music is created to be streamed from online services. These services remove the limitations of physical formats like records and CDs. This may be why many new albums are longer and have more songs than albums crafted for physical formats. Unfortunately, many of these longer albums suffer from a lack of focus.

Based on the texts, the author of Text 1 and the author of Text 2 would most likely agree with which statement about many new albums?

A) Many new albums are quieter than albums generally once were.

B) Many new albums sell more copies than albums generally once sold.

C) Many new albums are longer than albums generally once were.

D) Many new albums include more artwork than albums generally once included.

Stop
Both authors plainly share one claim about new albums. What is it? (One of them tacks on an extra opinion — set that aside; the question asks only what they agree on.)
Show answer
1

Step 1: Position each text.

Text 1Text 2
Records limited play time, so artists chose carefully; today there's no such limit, so many albums are much longerStreaming removes physical limits, so new albums are longer with more songs — but many "suffer from a lack of focus"
2

Step 2: Find the agreement.

Both say new albums are longer than they used to be. Text 2 adds a complaint (they lack focus) that Text 1 doesn't make — but the question asks only what they AGREE on.

3

Step 3: Test each answer against both texts.

AnswerText 1?Text 2?
A) Quieter than albums once were✗ volume not discussed✗ volume not discussed
B) Sell more copies than albums once sold✗ sales not discussed✗ sales not discussed
C) Longer than albums once were✓ "much longer than… decades past"✓ "longer and have more songs"
D) Include more artwork✗ artwork not discussed✗ artwork not discussed

Only C is supported by BOTH texts.

Answer: C

Note: Agreement can sit right next to disagreement. Both authors agree albums are longer; Text 2 also adds a judgment (they lack focus) that Text 1 never makes. Don't let that extra opinion pull you off — the question asks only what they BOTH hold.

Training 3: Free Time
Text 1

In a study of the benefits of having free time, Marissa Sharif found that the reported sense of life satisfaction tended to plateau when participants had two hours of free time per day and actually began to fall when they had five hours of free time per day. After further research, Sharif concluded that this dip in life satisfaction mainly occurred when individuals spent all their free time unproductively, such as by watching TV or playing games.

Text 2

Psychologist James Maddux cautions against suggesting an ideal amount of free time. The human desire for both free time and productivity is universal, but Maddux asserts that individuals have unique needs for life satisfaction. Furthermore, he points out that there is no objective definition for what constitutes productivity; reading a book might be considered a productive activity by some, but idleness by others.

Based on the texts, how would Maddux (Text 2) most likely respond to the conclusion Sharif (Text 1) reached after her further research?

A) By acknowledging that free time is more likely to enhance life satisfaction when it is spent productively than when it is spent unproductively

B) By challenging the reasoning in Text 1, as it has not been proved that productivity commonly contributes to individuals' life satisfaction

C) By warning against making an overly broad assumption, as there is no clear consensus in distinguishing between productive and unproductive activities

D) By claiming that the specific activities named in Text 1 are actually examples of productive activities rather than unproductive ones

Stop
Try this yourself first. What is Sharif's specific conclusion? What concern does Maddux raise that would challenge it?
Show answer
1

Step 1: Identify what Maddux would respond TO.

Sharif's conclusion: Life satisfaction drops when free time is spent "unproductively" (TV, games).

2

Step 2: Identify Maddux's relevant concern.

Maddux says: "There is no objective definition for what constitutes productivity."

3

Step 3: Match to answers.

Answer Evaluation
A) Acknowledging productive time is better ✗ Maddux would NOT acknowledge this—he questions the entire productive/unproductive distinction
B) Challenging that productivity contributes to satisfaction ✗ Maddux doesn't dispute the productivity-satisfaction link; he disputes the definition
C) Warning against overly broad assumption about productive vs. unproductive ✓ This is exactly Maddux's point
D) Claiming TV and games ARE productive ✗ Maddux doesn't reclassify specific activities; he questions the categories themselves

Answer: C

Note: Answer A is a common trap. "Acknowledging" sounds like partial agreement, which might seem reasonable for a "how would X respond" question. But check Text 2 carefully—Maddux never concedes that productive time is better. He challenges the very idea of distinguishing productive from unproductive. Don't assume concession unless the text supports it.

Training 4: Ollantay
Text 1

Ollantay is a play in Quechua, an Indigenous language in South America. The play portrays life in the Inca Empire before Spain invaded in the 1500s. Yet the oldest known text of the play is from 1770, and in many places its writing style resembles the writing style of Spanish plays from the 1700s. Thus, Ollantay was probably created in the late 1700s by someone who knew much about the Inca past.

Text 2

Ollantay includes details of Inca society that a writer in the 1700s wouldn't have known about. Also, the play's structure matches descriptions of the structure of Inca drama from the 1500s. The obvious explanation is that Ollantay itself is an Inca work from the 1500s. It could have been performed continuously from the 1500s to the 1700s. By the time it was written down in 1770, it could have easily been influenced by later Spanish plays.

Based on the texts, what do the author of Text 1 and the author of Text 2 mainly disagree about?

A) What inspired a Spanish writer in the 1700s to write a play about the Inca Empire

B) Whether Ollantay is an Inca play from the 1500s or was instead created much later, in the 1700s

C) How the Inca author of Ollantay knew so much about plays from Spain

D) Why Inca plays became more popular in the 1700s than they had been when first performed in the 1500s

Stop
Try this yourself first. What is the core claim each author makes? What's the fundamental disagreement?
Show answer
1

Step 1: Identify each position.

Text 1 Text 2
Ollantay was created in the 1700s (resembles Spanish style) Ollantay is from the 1500s (Inca origin, later influenced by Spanish)
2

Step 2: Find the fundamental conflict.

The core disagreement is about WHEN and by WHOM the play was created.

3

Step 3: Match to answers.

Answer Evaluation
A) What inspired a Spanish writer ✗ Text 2 doesn't say it was a Spanish writer at all
B) Whether from 1500s or 1700s ✓ This is exactly the disagreement
C) How the Inca author knew about Spanish plays ✗ Text 1 doesn't say there was an Inca author
D) Why Inca plays became more popular ✗ Neither text discusses popularity

Answer: B

Training 5: Female Birdsong
Text 1

For decades, ornithologists assumed that if they saw a singing Bell's vireo — a bird species found in temperate North America — they must be observing a male trying to attract a mate or claim territory. As Peter J.B. Slater and Nigel I. Mann have emphasized, however, a similar assumption can't be made about birds in the tropics, where females sing as often as males do. Slater and Mann call for more research on this discrepancy between tropical and temperate female birdsong.

Text 2

Recent evidence shows that a female Bell's vireo is as capable of song as a male is. In fact, female birdsong is more common among temperate species than currently assumed, claim Evangeline Rose and colleagues. These female songbirds sing less frequently than males do, and in duller tones, making it "easy for researchers to miss the quiet and hidden females and focus on the loud and colorful males," says Rose.

Based on the texts, how would Rose and colleagues (Text 2) most likely respond to the assertion by Slater and Mann (Text 1) about the different prevalence of female birdsong in temperate and tropical areas?

A) They would caution that the seeming difference in prevalence may be an artifact of researchers' tendency to study birdsong among temperate species more frequently than among tropical species.

B) They would concede that the geographic difference in prevalence is real but argue that the frequency with which male tropical birds sing has been overstated by previous researchers.

C) They would argue that the apparent difference in prevalence may partly reflect a difference in the ease with which female birdsong and male birdsong can be detected.

D) They would raise the possibility that the difference in prevalence may be due to differences in the timing of the mating season among temperate and tropical bird species.

Stop
What does Rose say explains why temperate female birdsong seems rare? Predict how she'd answer Slater and Mann before reading the choices — then watch for an answer that's the right type of explanation but the wrong specific reason.
Show answer
1

Step 1: Pin down Slater and Mann's claim (Text 1).

They treat the temperate-vs-tropical gap in female birdsong as real: females sing about as often as males in the tropics, apparently less so in temperate areas — and they call for research into why.

2

Step 2: Find Rose's relevant point (Text 2).

Rose says temperate female song is "more common… than currently assumed" because females sing more quietly and in duller tones, making them "easy for researchers to miss." So the apparent gap may be a detection problem, not a real difference.

3

Step 3: Match each answer to Rose's actual reasoning.

AnswerEvaluation
A) The gap is an artifact of studying temperate species more than tropical ones✗ Right kind of answer (a research bias) but the wrong bias — Rose's point is about missing females vs. males, not about studying one region more
B) Concede the gap is real, but say male tropical song has been overstated✗ False concession — Rose doesn't grant that the gap is real; she says temperate female song is underestimated
C) The gap may partly reflect how easily female vs. male song is detected✓ Exactly Rose's point — quiet, dull females get missed
D) The gap may be due to differences in mating-season timing✗ A new variable Rose never raises

Answer: C

Note: Two traps live here. B is a false concession — it has Rose AGREE the gap is real, which she doesn't. A is subtler: it's the right type of explanation (a research bias) but the wrong specific one — region study-frequency instead of Rose's actual point, the difficulty of detecting females. On "how would X respond," match the answer to the author's SPECIFIC reasoning, not just its general flavor.

Practice Questions

Question 1 (Easy)
Text 1

Imagine you and your friend are trying to decide where to eat lunch. When people try to make joint decisions like this, they often don’t reveal their true preferences. Instead, they say they would be happy with all options because they think this response will help them appear more easygoing and likable to the other person.

Text 2

Research shows that people who don’t state their preferences when making a decision with others aren’t more likable in the eyes of others. In fact, stating that you have no preference actually makes the decision more difficult for other people. It can also cause them to feel less happy with their ultimate decision and with you.

Based on the texts, what response would the author of Text 2 most likely suggest for someone in the situation described in the underlined sentence in Text 1?

A) Cancel the plan to have lunch together.

B) Ask where the friend typically likes to eat.

C) State a preference about where to eat.

D) Change the subject to talk about something else.

Show answer

Answer: C

Text 2 says “stating that you have no preference actually makes the decision more difficult for other people,” so the author of Text 2 would advise the person to state a preference about where to eat.

A — Introduces information not discussed — Text 2 never suggests canceling the plan.

B — Still avoids stating a preference, the very thing Text 2 says causes the problem.

D — Is off-topic / doesn’t answer the question — Text 2 says nothing about changing the subject.

Question 2 (Easy)
Text 1

From the extinct Shasta ground sloth to the living Hoffmann’s two-toed sloth, sloths are among the most appealing animals native to the Americas. But scientists still have a lot to learn about them. Unlike their ancient ground-dwelling relations, today’s sloths spend most of their time high up in trees. The sloths’ inaccessibility has made it hard for scientists to study them.

Text 2

By using a hat-like monitor, biologist Bryson Voirin and colleagues can at last discover the previously hidden activities of sloths. Such monitors can provide information to correct misconceptions. It was long believed that sloths are very gentle. But, in fact, sloths have very sharp claws and will attack if threatened.

Based on the texts, the author of Text 1 and the author of Text 2 would most likely agree with which statement about sloths?

A) Sloths typically live very long lives.

B) Sloths have been challenging to observe.

C) Sloths are usually unpleasant animals.

D) Sloths prefer certain types of trees over other types.

Show answer

Answer: B

Both authors treat sloths as hard to observe — Text 1 says so directly; Text 2 implies it (“at last,” “previously hidden”). Text 1: “inaccessibility has made it hard for scientists to study them”; Text 2: “can at last discover the previously hidden activities” — both agree they were hard to observe.

A — Reasonable But Not Stated — neither text mentions sloth lifespan.

C — Twists Passage Words — Text 1 calls them “among the most appealing animals”; Text 2 corrects only the “very gentle” belief, not a claim that they are usually unpleasant.

D — Reasonable But Not Stated — tree preference is discussed in neither text.

Question 3 (Easy)
Text 1

Despite how the Indian dish madras differs from Mauritius's gato pima, both dishes are described as a "curry." The word's history, however, is fraught. It's a term created by British and Portuguese colonizers to refer to the myriad spiced sauces with ties to the Indian subcontinent. In 1973, chef Madhur Jaffrey dismissed the term "curry" as inaccurate, and in 2021 blogger Nisha Vedi Pawar suggested that people abandon the term both for its colonial origin and for its failure to grasp the intricacies of India's cuisines.

Text 2

Growing up in India, chef Chintan Pandya didn't encounter the term "curry" often: his family didn't cook curries, but some of his neighbors did. Although the blanket use of the term is rooted in colonialism, Pandya calls some of his dishes curries. Having traveled throughout India as part of his training, he came to appreciate the country's diverse cuisines and the diverse uses of the term "curry."

Text 1 and Text 2 present points of view about which topic?

A) The history about the peoples on the Indian subcontinent

B) The use of the term "curry"

C) The difference between madras and gato pima

D) The best method for studying a region's cuisine

Show answer

Answer: B

Both texts present competing views on the word itself: Text 1 cites critics who urge people to “abandon the term both for its colonial origin” while Text 2's chef still calls some dishes curries.

A — Introduces information not discussed: the history of the subcontinent's peoples is never the subject of either text.

C — Too narrow: the “difference between madras and gato pima” is one detail in Text 1, not a point of view both texts argue about.

D — Off-topic: neither text debates the best method for studying a region's cuisine.

Question 4 (Easy)
Text 1

One challenge faced by researchers studying global urbanization is that countries may define urban settlements differently. Many countries define urban settlements based on the number of people living in them. However, countries do not all use the same number; for example, Iceland uses a minimum population of 200, while the Netherlands uses 20,000. Other countries use a combination of population and other factors. This variation makes it difficult for researchers to compare aspects of urbanization in different countries.

Text 2

Recently, a group of six international organizations developed global definitions of common types of settlements. The group developed a new measure called the “degree of urbanization.” This new measure establishes global criteria used to define three types of settlements (cities, towns, and rural areas) and allows researchers to better understand global urbanization rates.

Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the problem presented in Text 1?

A) By recommending that a specific institution should further investigate the problem

B) By suggesting that researchers focus on topics besides urbanization

C) By supplying additional ways in which urbanization research is difficult

D) By noting that a possible solution to the problem is available

Show answer

Answer: D

Text 1’s problem is inconsistent national definitions of urban settlements; Text 2 describes a new global “degree of urbanization” measure that “establishes global criteria,” so its author would note that a possible solution is available.

A — Introduces information not discussed — Text 2 names no institution to investigate further.

B — Contradicts the passage — Text 2 refines how urbanization is defined rather than abandoning the topic.

C — Reverses the direction — Text 2 offers a fix, not more difficulties.

Question 5 (Medium)
Text 1

In 2019 Belo Horizonte, Brazil, was named a City of Gastronomy by UNESCO in recognition of the city’s unique food culture. The honor is well known among residents of the city as well as tourists who visit. It’s obvious that the selection of Belo Horizonte by UNESCO has brought awareness to local recipes, cooking practices, and chefs and has provided a boost to the city’s tourism industry.

Text 2

Many people in Belo Horizonte’s restaurant industry hoped that food tourism would increase after the city was chosen as a City of Gastronomy in 2019. However, as researcher Ferang Park and colleagues argue, cities must still create effective marketing strategies to benefit fully from being named a City of Gastronomy. Without an intentional effort to promote the city’s food scene, many current and potential visitors to Belo Horizonte may not even be aware that it’s home to uniquely delicious food.

Based on the texts, what would the author of Text 2 most likely say in response to the underlined claim in Text 1?

A) Many people worked together to help Belo Horizonte be recognized by UNESCO, but chefs deserve the most credit for Belo Horizonte’s selection as a City of Gastronomy.

B) Belo Horizonte may have benefited from being selected by UNESCO, but tourism can likely be further increased by making more potential visitors aware of the city’s status as a City of Gastronomy.

C) The naming of Belo Horizonte as a City of Gastronomy was long overdue, given the city’s unique and delicious food.

D) The benefits of being named a City of Gastronomy extend well beyond tourism.

Show answer

Answer: B

Text 1 calls the tourism boost obvious, but Text 2 argues “cities must still create effective marketing strategies to benefit fully” from the title — so Text 2 would grant some benefit while saying more awareness could increase tourism further.

A — Unsupported: neither text claims chefs deserve the most credit for the UNESCO selection.

C — Wrong speaker: “long overdue” praise reflects Text 1's celebratory stance, not Text 2's qualifying argument.

D — Off-topic: Text 2 stays focused on whether tourism has been fully realized, not on benefits beyond tourism.

Question 6 (Medium)
Text 1

Norse settlers occupied part of Greenland from about 985 CE until the early 15th century, when they mysteriously abandoned the region. Many researchers cite increasingly lower temperatures to explain why the Norse fled. The researchers reason that the Norse settlers arrived in the region while the climate was warm and were able to remain there until temperatures declined during the Little Ice Age, which occurred between the 14th and 19th centuries.

Text 2

Jeffrey Salacup, Isla Castañeda, and colleagues analyzed sediment samples from a lake in Greenland close to the Norse settlement. This allowed them to reconstruct the area’s climate history. The researchers found no evidence of substantial temperature changes during the settlement period. They argue that instead the region experienced a persistent drought, which played a more important role in forcing the Norse out of the area than did increasingly lower temperatures.

Based on the texts, the researchers in both passages address which question?

A) Why did the Norse settlers abandon their settlement in Greenland?

B) What was the average global temperature during the Little Ice Age?

C) How often did the Norse settlers in Greenland experience drought?

D) Where was the first sediment sample of a Norse settlement found?

Show answer

Answer: A

Both texts answer: why did the Norse leave Greenland? (Text 1: cold; Text 2: drought.). Text 1 ("why the Norse fled") and Text 2 ("forcing the Norse out of the area") both answer this, offering competing causes.

B — Reasonable But Not Stated — neither text gives a global temperature figure; Text 2 explicitly found no substantial local temperature change.

C — Doesn't Answer the Question — only Text 2 mentions drought, and it does not address frequency; Text 1 never raises drought.

D — Doesn't Answer the Question — only Text 2 involves sediment, and "first sample" location is never addressed by either text.

Question 7 (Medium)
Text 1

Tool use in wild birds is rare and observed almost exclusively in foraging contexts, but male palm cockatoos create and employ tools in mating displays. Using their beaks to carve sticks and seedpods into drumstick-like percussive instruments, these birds then use the instruments they've made to repeatedly tap tree branches, creating rhythmic patterns that appear to be unique to individual birds.

Text 2

Not only are the percussive mating displays of male palm cockatoos idiosyncratic, so apparently are the tools used in them. A team of biologists compared discarded instruments made by 12 palm cockatoos and found that the tools varied in mass, length, and width significantly more than would occur through chance alone. Moreover, the team observed no evidence of imitation among the birds in the designs of their tools.

Based on the texts, the author of Text 1 and the team of biologists mentioned in Text 2 would most likely agree with which statement?

A) In creating and using tools for mating displays, male palm cockatoos exhibit evidence of individual preferences.

B) The tools that male palm cockatoos create and use for mating displays are also sometimes used for foraging.

C) Male palm cockatoos can create individualized percussive patterns even though their tools show little variation.

D) Although male palm cockatoos learn how to make tools through imitation, each bird eventually develops its own individual tool style.

Show answer

Answer: A

Text 1 says the rhythmic patterns “appear to be unique to individual birds” and Text 2 finds the tools vary far more than chance with no imitation between birds — both point to individual preference.

B — Contradicts Text 1: it presents the percussive tools as mating-display instruments, not foraging tools.

C — Contradicts Text 2: the tools varied significantly in mass, length, and width, not little.

D — Contradicts Text 2: it found no evidence of imitation, so the birds do not learn toolmaking by imitation.

Question 8 (Medium)
Text 1

Conventional wisdom long held that human social systems evolved in stages, beginning with hunter-gatherers forming small bands of members with roughly equal status. The shift to agriculture about 12,000 years ago sparked population growth that led to the emergence of groups with hierarchical structures: associations of clans first, then chiefdoms, and finally, bureaucratic states.

Text 2

In a 2021 book, anthropologist David Graeber and archaeologist David Wengrow maintain that humans have always been socially flexible, alternately forming systems based on hierarchy and collective ones with decentralized leadership. The authors point to evidence that as far back as 50,000 years ago some hunter-gatherers adjusted their social structures seasonally, at times dispersing in small groups but also assembling into communities that included esteemed individuals.

Based on the texts, how would Graeber and Wengrow (Text 2) most likely respond to the "conventional wisdom" presented in Text 1?

A) By conceding the importance of hierarchical systems but asserting the greater significance of decentralized collective societies

B) By disputing the idea that developments in social structures have followed a linear progression through distinct stages

C) By acknowledging that hierarchical roles likely weren't a part of social systems before the rise of agriculture

D) By challenging the assumption that groupings of hunter-gatherers were among the earliest forms of social structure

Show answer

Answer: B

Text 1 presents a fixed sequence (bands to clans to chiefdoms to states), but Graeber and Wengrow maintain “humans have always been socially flexible, alternately forming systems” based on hierarchy and decentralized leadership, contradicting the staged-progression idea.

A — Reasonable but not stated: they do not concede hierarchy's importance and then rank collective societies higher; they reject the linear framing itself.

C — Reverses their evidence: they cite hunter-gatherers assembling around “esteemed individuals” 50,000 years ago, so they would not agree hierarchy postdates agriculture.

D — Off-topic: Text 2 does not dispute that hunter-gatherer groupings were early; it disputes the stages that supposedly followed them.

Question 9 (Medium)
Text 1

An excavation in Chiquihuite Cave in central Mexico has upended the belief that approximately 13,000 years ago, a group known as the Clovis people were the first human inhabitants of North America. More than 200 crude stone tools were found embedded in a layer of earth that is up to 33,150 years old, revealing that humans occupied the cave thousands of years before the Clovis people reached the continent.

Text 2

The objects uncovered in Chiquihuite Cave are intriguing, but it is premature to characterize them as tools. The stone pieces are so roughly shaped that they may have simply fractured from rocks during natural geological activity in the cave. Moreover, their unearthing has thus far not been accompanied by discoveries of other signs of human activity or even traces of human DNA from surfaces.

Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the underlined claim in Text 1?

A) By suggesting that it draws a plausible connection between two groups of people but will need to be confirmed with further study

B) By asserting that it rests on an assumption about the stone pieces that is not sufficiently supported by available evidence

C) By acknowledging that it will most likely be proved correct when the stone pieces undergo more detailed analysis

D) By pointing out that it fails to account for evidence that the Clovis people were active on the continent as early as is commonly thought

Show answer

Answer: B

Text 2 says “it is premature to characterize them as tools” because the stone pieces may have fractured naturally and no other signs of human activity were found — so Text 1's claim rests on an unsupported assumption.

A — Understates Text 2's stance: Text 2 disputes the claim's premise rather than calling its connection plausible but unconfirmed.

C — Reverses Text 2: it expects the “tools” interpretation to fail scrutiny, not to be proved correct.

D — Introduces information not discussed: Text 2 never argues about when the Clovis people were active.

Question 10 (Medium)
Text 1

The poet Audre Lorde once claimed that poetry is the most inexpensive of art forms to practice. While people who pursue other art forms—sculpture, architecture, theater—require large blocks of uninterrupted time as well as money to complete their work, poets can write, as Lorde said, “between shifts, in the hospital pantry, on the subway, and on scraps of surplus paper.” So poets can make worthwhile art even if they must earn their living in another way.

Text 2

Any assessment of the state of contemporary poetry must reckon with the professionalization of the field. While it is possible in theory for anyone to publish in Poetry, Kenyon Review, or a similar major poetry outlet, many people who do so have professional training in poetry and extensive practice writing it, which requires time not often available to those who must also work full-time jobs. Thus, financial security indirectly affects which people become poets.

Based on the texts, how would Lorde (Text 1) most likely respond to the argument presented in Text 2?

A) By indicating that those poets who publish in major poetry journals are most likely to be able to earn a living by writing poetry

B) By pointing out that people can produce valuable poetry in other circumstances than those described by the author of Text 2

C) By suggesting that those artists who specialize in more financially rewarding artistic forms are unlikely to also be successful as poets

D) By asserting that people often work full-time jobs in order to afford the professional training described in Text 2

Show answer

Answer: B

Lorde holds that poets “can write… between shifts, in the hospital pantry, on the subway” and “make worthwhile art even if they must earn their living in another way” — a direct rebuttal to Text 2’s claim that financial security gates who becomes a poet.

A — Misattributes a view to Lorde (she never ties earning a living to journal publication).

C — Is unsupported (Lorde says nothing about practitioners of financially rewarding art forms).

D — Restates Text 2’s premise rather than Lorde’s response.

Question 11 (Medium)
Text 1

With a shell that measured 1.7 meters, the extinct mollusk Parapuzosia seppenradensis is the largest ammonite in the fossil record. Ever since fossilized remains of this large ammonite were first discovered in 1895, scientists have been perplexed by its size. After examining 154 ammonite fossils including P. seppenradensis fossils from Texas and Parapuzosia leptophylla (a smaller ammonite species) fossils from England, paleontologist Christina Ifrim, Arturo H. González-González, and colleagues concluded that P. seppenradensis may have evolved from P. leptophylla and gradually increased in size as larger ammonites were better able to escape being preyed on by mosasaurs.

Text 2

Christina Ifrim and her team have expanded our understanding of the evolutionary history of ammonites in general, but their study has some gaps that will require additional research to fill. For instance, there’s evidence that mosasaurs preyed on ammonites, but there’s no direct evidence that they interacted specifically with P. seppenradensis.

Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely characterize the study conducted by Ifrim, González-González, and colleagues in Text 1?

A) It is correct with regard to P. seppenradensis, but its claims about P. leptophylla are likely overstated.

B) It is relevant to the study of ammonites, but it overlooks the evolutionary history of mosasaurs.

C) It is useful for the field as a whole, but a portion of it might be unfounded.

D) It is likely to become outdated quickly, but it features an impressive amount of data.

Show answer

Answer: C

Text 2 says the team “expanded our understanding… in general” (useful for the field) “but their study has some gaps” and there’s “no direct evidence” for the mosasaur–P. seppenradensis interaction (a portion might be unfounded).

A — Overstates Text 2 (it never calls the P. leptophylla claims overstated).

B — Twists Text 2 (it faults missing evidence about P. seppenradensis, not a neglect of mosasaur evolution).

D — Introduces information not discussed (Text 2 says nothing about the amount of data or rapid obsolescence).

Question 12 (Medium)
Text 1

Isaac Asimov, author of The Naked Sun and Pebble in the Sky, is highly regarded despite his mediocre writing style. His prose is workmanlike; his characters are flat and discuss ideas rather than emotions. That his work is enjoyable despite this is a testament to his prodigious imagination — even if people read his books only for the ideas, they will have plenty to consider.

Text 2

Asimov is critiqued for his style, but it is wrong to fault a writer for failing to do what he never intended to do. For example, although most of his novel Foundation consists of people discussing science and politics and we find out little about his characters' lives, Asimov wanted to convey the vast sweep of human history over centuries, and one of his points is that at such a timescale, individuals don't matter. Thus his lack of characterization is central to his thematic aims.

Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the description of Asimov's characters in the underlined portion of Text 1?

A) Asimov's characterizations would have been richer if he had possessed a deeper understanding of history.

B) The flatness of Asimov's characters is a feature of The Naked Sun and Pebble in the Sky but not of Foundation.

C) Asimov's characterizations would have been more believable if his writing had discussed fewer ideas.

D) The flatness of Asimov's characters should not necessarily be considered a flaw in his writing.

Show answer

Answer: D

Text 2: "wrong to fault a writer for failing to do what he never intended" and flatness "central to his thematic aims" — so it is not necessarily a flaw.

A — Contradicts Text 2: Text 2 says the flatness is intentional and central, not a deficiency to be fixed.

B — Contradicts Text 2: Text 2 uses Foundation as its prime example of intentional flatness.

C — Contradicts Text 2: Text 2 defends the idea-focused, lightly characterized approach as purposeful.

Question 13 (Medium)
Text 1

To many artists in the mid-nineteenth-century United States, the American wilderness symbolized innocence and untouched beauty. So George Inness's decision to foreground a railroad in his 1855 painting The Lackawanna Valley is notable, since images of railroads often alluded to the destruction of wilderness in the name of progress. In fact, art historian Nicolai Cikovsky Jr. argues that Inness glorifies the subject of the railroad by painting a scene that suggests hopefulness rather than devastation.

Text 2

It is impossible to deduce anything about George Inness's attitude toward his subject in the painting The Lackawanna Valley, primarily because it is a commissioned work. Inness was restricted in how he could portray the Delaware, Lackawanna and Western Railroad Company: his client was the company's first president, who had requested the painting possibly as a way to promote the company's rail network.

Which choice best describes a difference in how the author of Text 1 and the author of Text 2 view the painting The Lackawanna Valley?

A) The author of Text 1 claims that the painting is an accurate representation of a physical place, whereas the author of Text 2 identifies several embellishments that Inness made to alter the scene.

B) The author of Text 1 implies that the styles and themes of the painting are atypical of Inness's body of work, whereas the author of Text 2 claims that the painting is representative of Inness as a painter.

C) The author of Text 1 suggests that the painting can reveal information about Inness's opinions, whereas the author of Text 2 believes that the circumstances of the painting's production prohibit such an interpretation.

D) The author of Text 1 emphasizes the painting's similarities to the works of other painters at the time, whereas the author of Text 2 uses the painting to exemplify a contrast between Inness and some of his contemporaries.

Show answer

Answer: C

Text 1 says Inness "glorifies" the railroad with a hopeful scene — the painting reveals his attitude; Text 2 says it is "impossible to deduce anything about … Inness's attitude" because it was a commissioned, constrained work.

A — Is unsupported — neither text discusses physical accuracy or "embellishments".

B — Misreads both — Text 1 doesn't call the painting atypical of Inness, and Text 2 doesn't call it representative of him.

D — Is off — Text 1 doesn't stress similarities to other painters, and Text 2 doesn't contrast Inness with contemporaries.

Question 14 (Medium)
Text 1

Toni Morrison's 1973 novel Sula, a tale of two women's lives set in small-town Ohio from the 1910s to the 1960s, has been described as historical fiction. While it's inarguable that Morrison's book takes place in the past rather than in her own time, Sula is much richer and more complicated than the mere re-creation of the past suggested by the term "historical fiction."

Text 2

Some literary critics dismiss historical fiction as a shallow genre in which writers show off their knowledge of period details rather than tell meaningful stories. But historical fiction can be used to explore profound themes and complex characters — in fact, many writers find that writing about the past gives them a creative freedom they'd lack if they wrote about the present.

Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the claim about Sula advanced by the author of Text 1?

A) By arguing that Morrison displays a thorough knowledge of historical details in Sula

B) By asserting that dissatisfaction with describing Sula as historical fiction reflects a misunderstanding of the genre

C) By conceding that the genre of historical fiction contains many works that are less sophisticated than Sula is

D) By claiming that the author of Text 1 has underestimated the richness and complexity of Sula

Show answer

Answer: B

Text 1 finds the historical-fiction label too reductive for Sula, but Text 2 argues “historical fiction can be used to explore profound themes and complex characters” — so it would call that discomfort a misunderstanding of the genre.

A — Wrong side of Text 2: showing off period details is the dismissive view Text 2 rejects, not a response defending the label.

C — Unsupported concession: Text 2 defends the genre's depth rather than conceding it contains many works less sophisticated than Sula.

D — Misreads Text 1: Text 1 praises Sula's richness; it questions the label, so Text 2 would not say Text 1 underestimated the novel.

Question 15 (Medium)
Text 1

In parts of Finland, the mink is a major predator of the common frog. Researcher Markus Ahola and colleagues found that when this predation pressure on common frogs was temporarily reduced, their numbers significantly increased. This finding illustrates a foundational ecological principle: predators control prey population numbers.

Text 2

William D. Gulsby and colleagues found that excluding coyotes from a site in the state of Georgia where they typically prey on white-tailed deer had no significant effect on white-tailed deer abundance. Many other predation relief studies show an increase in prey abundance, but those studies often focus on small, rapidly reproducing prey, like birds, frogs, and rodents, rather than large, slowly reproducing prey, like white-tailed deer, which could account for the difference between those results and Gulsby and colleagues' results.

Based on the texts, the author of Text 2 would most likely agree with which statement about the "principle" mentioned in Text 1?

A) It has been challenged by some studies, but the findings of those studies have not been widely accepted.

B) It may be true for some predators but only because those predators share certain physical characteristics.

C) It is plausible, but many of the studies that support it have methodological flaws.

D) It has some evidential support, but it should not be regarded as universally applicable.

Show answer

Answer: D

Text 2 grants that “Many other predation relief studies show an increase in prey abundance,” yet its own coyote-deer result shows the principle fails for large, slowly reproducing prey — so it has support but is not universal.

A — Twists the passage: Text 2 never says the contrary findings were rejected or not widely accepted; it offers its own contrary finding.

B — Introduces information not discussed: Text 2 attributes the difference to reproduction rate, not to predators' physical characteristics.

C — Unsupported: Text 2 never alleges that the supporting studies have methodological flaws, only that they used different prey.

Question 16 (Hard)
Text 1

Vernacular art, also known as folk art, refers to works by artists without extensive training who work outside the mainstream art world. In the last few decades, the Minneapolis Institute of Art and similar cultural institutions have worked to bring vernacular art out of obscurity. As a result, Nellie Mae Rowe's drawing Rocking Chair can now be experienced by art lovers.

Text 2

Special exhibits and similar efforts by cultural institutions to promote vernacular artists often inadvertently uphold misleading distinctions between these artists and the creators of so-called "high" art. Artists regularly gain inspiration from each other: vernacular artists often reveal a familiarity with prevailing trends through their works, and more mainstream artists in turn often credit vernacular works as important influences.

Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the author of Text 1's characterization of vernacular artists?

A) By questioning the argument made in Text 1 that the general public will readily embrace works by vernacular artists as those works are brought to greater attention

B) By suggesting that the author of Text 1 may be overstating the extent to which vernacular artists have been detached from the mainstream art world

C) By agreeing with the author of Text 1 that some of the terms used to describe vernacular artists may be misleading

D) By challenging the idea advanced in Text 1 that mainstream cultural institutions are suitable venues for adequately honoring vernacular artists

Show answer

Answer: B

Text 2 would push back on Text 1's "outside the mainstream" characterization, saying the separation is overstated. Exactly Text 2's stance: the "outside the mainstream" framing upholds "misleading distinctions," since the two groups actually influence each other.

A — Doesn't answer the question: neither text discusses public reception; Text 1 doesn't argue the public will "readily embrace" the works.

C — Twists Text 2 and misreads Text 1: Text 1 never calls its terms misleading, and Text 2 challenges the distinctions, not the terminology — it is not agreement.

D — Wrong scope: Text 2's critique is about misleading distinctions between the artist groups, not about whether institutions are suitable display venues.

Question 17 (Hard)
Text 1

When the 50-second-long film Arrival of the Train—which depicts what its title says, a train pulling into a station—was first shown publicly in 1896, spectators, naïve to the new medium of film and seeing a train appearing to come directly at them, leaped from their seats and fled the room. This moment marks a major cultural shift: a new way of representing and seeing the world had arrived with that train, and nothing would ever be the same.

Text 2

The fact that there is no contemporary evidence that the first audience of Arrival of the Train was alarmed has not stopped the story from becoming canonical, even among film historians. But that phenomenon itself is highly revealing. Our belief that the coming of film was transformative is so strong that we invented and keep retelling a founding myth that divides cultural history into a (naïve) “before” and (sophisticated) “after.”

Based on the texts, the author of Text 2 would most likely agree with which statement about the description of the first showing of Arrival of the Train in Text 1?

A) It is more motivated by a perception of the significance of the invention of film than by facts.

B) It expresses a view about the transformative nature of film that film historians tend to regard as naïve.

C) It is not based on evidence and reflects film historians’ belief that they are more sophisticated than today’s audiences.

D) It reflects a misconception that is widely believed because it captures early film audiences’ sense that the new medium was alarming.

Show answer

Answer: A

Text 2 says there is “no contemporary evidence” the first audience was alarmed, yet the story persists because “our belief that the coming of film was transformative is so strong” — i.e., the Text 1 account is driven by a perception of film’s significance, not facts.

B — Contradicts the passage — Text 2 says the story is “canonical, even among film historians,” not that they regard it as naive.

C — Twists the meaning — the “before/after” divide is naive-vs-sophisticated eras generally, not film historians claiming superiority over today’s audiences.

D — Contradicts the passage — Text 2 stresses there is no evidence audiences were actually alarmed, so it does not “capture” their sense.

Question 18 (Hard)
Text 1

Scholarship today overrepresents experimentally fragmented narrative structures, such as that of Flann O'Brien's At Swim-Two-Birds, beyond the degree to which they actually influenced fiction in Britain and Ireland during the modernist period (roughly 1900–1945). Meanwhile, Elizabeth Bowen's The Last September, whose coherent, linear narrative structure recalls the fiction of previous centuries, attracts woefully little attention from scholars of modernism.

Text 2

Distant reading, or computer-assisted quantitative analysis of massive collections of digitized texts, can reveal stylistic elements that have heretofore escaped notice, despite being shared by numerous texts from the modernist period. For too long, scholars have focused on narrative fragmentation versus coherence, inhibiting inquiry into other points of stylistic correspondence among works that would enrich our understanding of the modernist canon.

Based on the texts, both authors would most likely agree with which statement about scholarship on works from the modernist period in Britain and Ireland?

A) It must widen its focus to include aspects of modernist fiction beyond style, a productive but overrepresented area of inquiry.

B) Without a major shift in focus, the vision that it presents of fiction written in the period will continue to be unnecessarily limited.

C) Instead of engaging in unproductive debates, it should work to rehabilitate the reputations of neglected modernist works.

D) Its primary methods for analyzing fiction written in the period are growing obsolete as computer technology advances.

Show answer

Answer: B

Both authors say the field's narrow focus distorts the picture: Text 1 faults the overrepresentation of fragmented structures, and Text 2 says “scholars have focused on narrative fragmentation versus coherence, inhibiting inquiry” into other patterns.

A — Reverses Text 2's point: Text 2 wants more stylistic inquiry, not a move beyond style; it does not call style overrepresented.

C — Twists the texts: neither calls the debate merely “unproductive,” and only Text 1 is concerned with rehabilitating neglected works.

D — Misattributes a view to both: only Text 2 discusses computer methods; Text 1 is silent on whether existing methods are obsolete.

Question 19 (Hard)
Text 1

Sidebells wintergreen (Orthilia secunda) plants are native to Alaska, where harsh conditions have historically impeded potential invasive species. As the boreal climate has warmed in recent decades, however, Siberian peashrub (Caragana arborescens) plants have established themselves in Alaska. Previous research conducted in non-boreal ecosystems has documented warming-induced increases in summer temperatures benefiting invasive species more than native species.

Text 2

At a site near Fairbanks, Alaska, Christa Mulder and Katie Spellman tracked O. secunda and C. arborescens, along with other native and invasive species, over several years. They observed that although average summer temperatures were substantially higher in some years of the study than in others, neither O. secunda nor C. arborescens showed any significant variation in summer growth patterns from year to year.

Which choice best describes the relationship between the two texts?

A) Text 2 describes a methodology that helps researchers avoid a problem encountered in the studies discussed in Text 1.

B) Text 2 explains a study that suggests an alternative explanation for the trend observed in the research discussed in Text 1.

C) Text 2 discusses an observation that challenges the validity of the findings described in Text 1.

D) Text 2 presents a finding that casts doubt on the generalizability of the research discussed in Text 1.

Show answer

Answer: D

Text 2's boreal result doesn't fit what the non-boreal research would predict, so it questions whether that research extends to boreal contexts. Text 1: “Previous research conducted in non-boreal ecosystems has documented warming-induced increases in summer temperatures benefiting invasive species more than native species.”; Text 2: “neither O. secunda nor C. arborescens showed any significant variation in summer growth patterns”.

A — Doesn't answer the relationship: Text 2 reports an observation, not a method that fixes a problem in Text 1's studies.

B — Twists the passage: Text 2 finds no year-to-year trend, so it offers no alternative explanation for a trend.

C — Overstates: Text 2 doesn't say the non-boreal findings are invalid — just that the pattern doesn't hold in this boreal setting.

Question 20 (Hard)
Text 1

In separate studies, Marine Fernandez and colleagues and Xinhua He and colleagues examined whether plants transfer nutrients to one another using a common mycorrhizal network (CMN) --- a lattice of fungal strands in the soil. Fernandez and colleagues excluded all pathways other than the CMN by using barriers to keep the plants' root systems separate while allowing mycorrhizal strands through --- a crucial step He and colleagues' study did not take.

Text 2

Fernandez and colleagues took the necessary precaution of separating the plants' root systems (thereby excluding root-to-root transmission). However, any barrier used must allow the thread-like hyphae of a CMN to pass through, and this permeability would also allow liquids through. Thus, the researchers' experimental design cannot ensure that any nutrient transfer observed can be attributed to a CMN and not to some other pathway.

Based on the texts, which choice best describes a similarity in the points of view presented in Text 1 and Text 2?

A) Each text attempts to dispel a common misunderstanding about the likelihood of plant-to-plant nutrient transfer.

B) Each text assumes that most nutrient transfer between plants is via a CMN.

C) Each text analyzes methods for studying CMN nutrient transfer in order to propose an alternative method of study.

D) Each text critiques the methodology of a study about nutrient transfer via a CMN.

Show answer

Answer: D

Each text faults a CMN study's methods: Text 1 says He and colleagues failed to separate root systems, while Text 2 says even Fernandez's barrier lets liquids through, so “the researchers' experimental design cannot ensure” the transfer came via a CMN.

A — Unsupported: neither text sets out to dispel a common misunderstanding about whether plant-to-plant transfer occurs.

B — Reverses the texts: both scrutinize whether transfer is via a CMN rather than assuming most of it is.

C — Introduces information not discussed: neither text proposes an alternative method of study.

Question 21 (Hard)
Text 1

Kikko (tortoiseshell) and other Japanese sashiko embroidery patterns use motifs drawn from nature and daily activities; classics sources of inspiration in folk-art traditions. A category that resists firm delineation, folk art is generally defined by an intimate connection to quotidian life. "The beauty of such objects," writes Soetsu Yanagi in The Unknown Craftsman, "is not so much of the noble, the huge, or the lofty as a beauty of the warm and familiar."

Text 2

Through their beautiful handmade aesthetic, painting and textiles from Japan's twentieth-century mingei (folk art) movement represent an unambiguous rejection of mass-produced consumer goods. At the same time, mingei, properly considered, stands apart from fine art, as its rootedness in commonplace craft traditions gives it an authenticity and accessibility that fine art, with its prizing of sophistication and innovation, cannot match.

Which choice best describes how Text 1 differs from Text 2?

A) Both texts highlight the principally utilitarian nature of folk-art objects, but Text 1 acknowledges a complementary decorative function that is not mentioned in Text 2.

B) Text 1 suggests that the nature-based aesthetic of folk art is inherently resistant to change, while Text 2 implies that the pressures of consumer culture have indirectly altered how folk art is made.

C) Text 1 identifies characteristics shared by folk art across cultural contexts, while Text 2 describes how a universal characteristic of folk art is manifest within a specific tradition.

D) Both texts valorize folk-art traditions, but Text 1 does so by emphasizing qualities that are intrinsic to folk art, whereas Text 2 makes reference to other modes of cultural production.

Show answer

Answer: D

Both admire folk art; Text 1 via intrinsic qualities, Text 2 by referencing other modes of cultural production. Text 1: "intimate connection to quotidian life" (intrinsic); Text 2: defined against "mass-produced consumer goods" and "fine art" (other modes).

A — Not stated: neither text frames folk art as "principally utilitarian," and Text 1 makes no decorative-vs-utilitarian point.

B — Not stated: Text 1 never calls folk art change-resistant; Text 2 says mingei rejects mass production, not that consumer culture altered its making.

C — Twists the passage's words: Text 2's point is a contrast with fine art and mass production, not one universal trait shown in a single tradition.

Question 22 (Hard)
Text 1

Studies contributing to the body of evidence that people generally enjoy socializing have routinely focused on interactions in ongoing relationships (from spouses to classmates), but psychologist Selin Salman-Engin and colleagues have demonstrated the benefit of making connections with strangers. Greater positive affect was reported by participants in their study who warmly thanked a shuttle driver than by those who didn't speak to the driver.

Text 2

Social relations research commonly draws on a model that centers an individual within three concentric circles. The innermost circle holds one's strongest ties (e.g., a treasured friend), the next holds close but less important ties (e.g., a teammate), and the outermost holds weak ties (those more distant but important enough to be counted as part of one's social network).

Based on the texts, what would Salman-Engin and colleagues (Text 1) most likely say about the discussion of the model in Text 2?

A) It underscores that most research on social interactions fails to capture a category of connection that has the capacity to contribute positively to individuals' sense of well-being.

B) It reflects an overemphasis on relationship longevity in researchers' evaluations of the relative importance of various connections in an individual's social network.

C) It explains researchers' observations that individuals typically expect interactions with familiar people to be more positive than their interactions with unfamiliar people would be.

D) It emphasizes distinctions among types of close connections that aren't adequately represented in social relations research, since most studies categorize relationships as either close or casual.

Show answer

Answer: A

Salman-Engin and colleagues “demonstrated the benefit of making connections with strangers” but Text 2's three-circle model counts only ties already in one's network, so it misses a well-being-boosting category of connection.

B — Twists the model: Text 2 ranks ties by strength and importance, not by relationship longevity.

C — Reasonable but not stated: Text 1 measured reported affect after the interaction, not people's expectations about familiar versus unfamiliar others.

D — Reverses the gap: the model does distinguish among close ties; what it omits is strangers, not finer gradations of closeness.

Question 23 (Hard)
Text 1

Good art often challenges and disrupts social and aesthetic norms, but the creation of public art—paintings, sculptures, and performance pieces displayed in nonmuseum or nontheatrical public settings—typically requires broad agreement among artists, civic officials, and community members about the works' message and artistic goals. Public art that fails to appease everyone by being sufficiently aesthetically and conceptually bland almost inevitably provokes backlash.

Text 2

Public art is commonly displayed in spaces intended for purposes other than meaningful aesthetic engagement. Some critics of public art therefore note that norm-defying pieces that aren't effectively integrated within their surroundings in a manner that primes passersby to appreciate the pieces' merits (as is often the case) tend to be regarded more unfavorably than similarly provocative art encountered in museums is.

Based on the texts, how would the critics mentioned in Text 2 most likely respond to the underlined claim in Text 1?

A) By disputing the notion that civic leaders and community members are easily placated by art that is intended mainly to reinforce social norms

B) By agreeing with the idea that only works of art that are universally appealing are suitable for displaying in public spaces

C) By arguing that the reason members of the general public might disagree about a public artwork's merits is unrelated to the unconventionality of its appearance and ideas

D) By contending that the kinds of reactions controversial public artworks often receive aren't exclusively the result of attributes inherent in the works themselves

Show answer

Answer: D

Text 1's underlined claim is that provocative public art "almost inevitably provokes backlash" — i.e., the backlash comes from the work's own boldness. The Text 2 critics say norm-defying pieces are judged unfavorably when "not effectively integrated within their surroundings," so reception depends partly on context, not solely the artwork itself — that is D ("aren't exclusively the result of attributes inherent in the works").

A — Misattributes a view — the critics never discuss whether leaders are "easily placated" by norm-reinforcing art.

B — Reverses the critics' position: they explain unfavorable reception by poor contextual integration, not by endorsing that only "universally appealing" art belongs in public.

C — Overstates to "unrelated to the unconventionality" — the critics still grant the art is "provocative/norm-defying"; they add context as a factor, they don't deny unconventionality plays any role.

Question 24 (Hard)
Text 1

Hycean planets are a class of exoplanets (planets outside our solar system) with oceans of liquid water --- critical to supporting life-and atmospheres rich in hydrogen. Computer models have determined that for potential hycean planets, the range of the habitable zone(HZ), the distance from a star that allows a planet to retain liquid water on its surface, begins at about 1 astronomical unit (AU). In 2021, Nikku Madhusudhan et al. identified K2-18b as a hycean candidate, noting that the planet is located right on the inner edge of the HZ

Text 2

In a 2023 paper, Shang-Min Tsai et al. claimed that the hydrogen-rich atmospheres of K2-18b and other hycean candidates admit wavelengths of light that cause elevated surface temperatures and increased water evaporation. Unlike earlier assessments, Tsai et al.'s calculations therefore placed the inner edge for these planets' HZ as far out as 3.85 AU.

Based on the texts, how would Tsai et al. (Text 2) most likely respond to Madhusudhan et al.'s research, as presented in Text 1?

A) By observing that unlike the hycean candidate Madhusudhan et al. discovered most other types of planets with hydrogen-rich atmospheres are likely located within the HZ

B) By maintaining that Madhusudhan et al, relied on a model whose estimates of surface temperatures on hycean candidates are likely too high

C) By arguing that K2-18 b and other hycean candidates are unlikely to support life because these planets are located too far from the stars they orbit

D) By stating that the chemical composition of the atmosphere of the hycean candidate Madhusudhan et al, identified suggests that this planet's surface is unlikely to harbor liquid water

Show answer

Answer: D

Madhusudhan et al. place K2-18b right at the inner HZ edge near 1 AU, but Tsai et al. say hydrogen-rich atmospheres cause “elevated surface temperatures and increased water evaporation” that push that edge out to 3.85 AU — so K2-18b is too hot for surface liquid water.

A — Off-topic and reversed: Tsai et al. argue these atmospheres push planets outside the HZ, not that most such planets sit within it.

B — Reverses Text 2: Tsai et al. say the actual surface temperatures are too high, not that a model's estimates are too high.

C — Contradicts the figures: K2-18b sits near 1 AU, inside the new 3.85 AU edge, so it is too close to its star, not too far.

Question 25 (Hard)
Text 1

Chemically analyzing bulk rock-core samples from Australia's Mount McRae Shale, Ariel Anbar et al. found a transient but significant increase in molybdenum (Mo) at a point corresponding to roughly 2.5 billion years ago (Ga). On Earth, Mo is released mainly through oxidative weathering of minerals; Anbar et al. therefore concluded that atmospheric oxygen briefly increased 2.5 Ga, then returned to its earlier negligible level.

Text 2

Sarah Slotznick et al. reexamined the Mount McRae Shale core. Since chemically analyzing bulk samples can occlude contextual details, Slotznick et al. also employed high-resolution microscopy, which revealed volcanic debris--a known Mo host--around 2.5 Ga and microfractures in the surrounding matrix. The researchers assert that fluid could have reached the debris through the microfractures and initiated oxidative weathering long after debris deposition.

Based on the texts, Anbar et al. (Text 1) and Slotznick et al. (Text 2) would most likely disagree about the answer to which question about the portion of the Mount McRae Shale rock-core corresponding to 2.5 Ga?

A) Is the increase in Mo in that portion indicative of an increase in atmospheric oxygen dating to the same time?

B) Does the increase in Mo in that portion suggest that atmospheric oxygen levels were not negligible before 2.5 Ga?

C) Did chemically analyzing bulk samples lead to a false impression that there is an increase in Mo in that portion?

D) Is the increase in Mo in that portion attributable to oxidative weathering of the material found in that portion?

Show answer

Answer: A

Anbar et al. read the Mo spike as a sign that “atmospheric oxygen briefly increased 2.5 Ga,” while Slotznick et al. say fluid through microfractures could have weathered volcanic debris long after deposition — so they disagree on whether the Mo dates oxygen to that time.

B — No disagreement: both treat pre-2.5 Ga oxygen as negligible, since Text 1 says it “returned to its earlier negligible level.”

C — Misframes Text 2: Slotznick et al. do not deny the Mo increase exists; they dispute its cause and timing.

D — No disagreement: both attribute the Mo to oxidative weathering; they differ on when that weathering happened.

Question 26 (Hard)

Text 1 is adapted from E.M. Forster's 1910 novel Howards End. Text 2 discusses Howards End. King's Cross and St. Pancras are adjacent railway terminals in London from which trains travel to the countryside.

Text 1

To Margaret the station of King's Cross had always suggested Infinity. Its very situation—withdrawn a little behind the facile splendours of St. Pancras—implied a comment on the materialism of life. Those two great arches, colourless, indifferent, shouldering between them an unlovely clock, were fit portals for some eternal adventure, whose issue might be prosperous, but would certainly not be expressed in the ordinary language of prosperity.

Text 2

The interplay between opposing ideological positions in Howards End is broadly articulated in the novel's organization of geographic space. On the one hand, the modern metropolis of London represents capitalism's emphasis on pragmatism and the accumulation of material wealth; on the other, the English countryside, accessible via King's Cross, fosters an idealism that values tradition, authentic personal connection, and the aesthetic—what the novel calls "the infinite."

Based on the texts, the author of Text 2 would most likely agree with which statement about King's Cross, as it is depicted in Text 1?

A) As a point of connection between London and the countryside, King's Cross suggests to Margaret the possibility of acquiring the intangible abundance promised by the kinds of authentic engagements that the novel's rural spaces seem to offer.

B) Because it is situated at the beginning of Margaret's journey from the city to the country, King's Cross emblematizes the intrusion of the forces of materialism and modernity into the rural spaces that the novel associates with idealism and tradition.

C) The austerity conveyed by King's Cross's appearance mirrors Margaret's disillusionment with the prospect of having authentic connections with other people in a world that chiefly values more conventional forms of prosperity.

D) King's Cross has a relatively unassuming appearance whose sharp contrast with the more aesthetically pleasing appearance of St. Pancras suggests to Margaret the ascendancy of the pragmatic capitalistic outlook among London's inhabitants.

Show answer

Answer: A

Text 2 says the countryside reached via King's Cross “fosters an idealism that values tradition,” authentic connection, and the aesthetic; Text 1 has Margaret link the station to Infinity and eternal adventure beyond ordinary prosperity, matching that intangible abundance.

B — Reverses the direction: King's Cross is the gateway out to the countryside's idealism, not an intrusion of materialism into rural space.

C — Misreads Margaret's tone: she sees “eternal adventure,” not disillusionment with authentic connection.

D — Misreads the contrast: Margaret views the plain station positively, not as proof of capitalism's ascendancy.

Question 27 (Hard)
Text 1

Thomas Piketty's book Capital in the Twenty-First Century has a more rigorous structure than its sequel, Capital and Ideology. While the first book's chapters all contribute to bolstering a clear, coherent argument about income inequality, the second book's digressions on subjects such as an analysis of Hayao Miyazaki's film The Wind Rises do not just unduly lengthen the book but also muddy its reasoning.

Text 2

Capital and Ideology has different aims than Piketty's earlier books. It should be judged not just in the context of Piketty's previous work but placed next to books like William T. Vollmann's Rising Up and Rising Down, in which the stated theme is mainly an excuse for a polymath to map his own mind. Even when sections do not explicitly support the central thesis, they link to each other in intriguing ways. None of them should be considered extraneous.

Based on the texts, the author of Text 1 would most likely agree with the author of Text 2 on which point?

A) Capital and Ideology was influenced by the writing of William T. Vollmann.

B) Capital in the Twenty-First Century is a superior book to Capital and Ideology.

C) Capital and Ideology is notably different in structure from some of Piketty's earlier work.

D) The material in Capital and Ideology on The Wind Rises is essential to the book.

Show answer

Answer: C — Both authors agree that Capital and Ideology differs in structure from Piketty's earlier work. Text 1 says it's less rigorously structured than the first book (its digressions "muddy its reasoning"); Text 2 says it has "different aims" and shouldn't be judged only against his earlier books. They disagree on whether that difference is a flaw — but both acknowledge the difference itself.

A — Not supported: Text 2 compares the book to Vollmann's, but never claims Vollmann influenced it.

B — Text 1 implies it, but Text 2 defends Capital and Ideology and wouldn't agree it's the inferior book — fails the both-texts test.

D — Reverses the texts: Text 1 calls the Wind Rises digression something that "muddies reasoning," not essential; only Text 2 says nothing is "extraneous."